Karen M. Overtoom Logo
Your connection to all Martha's Vineyard Real Estate and Vacation Rentals
508-693-7832
Karen M. Overtoom Logo
508-693-7832

West Tisbury Village Charming Farmhouse & Converted Barn

"Restored West Tisbury Farm House. Antique Furnishings, Open Floor Plan, Large Deck."

  • McClennenM10018%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5Flivingroom%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5Fkitchen%2Ejpg
  • McClennenM1004%2Ejpg
  • McC%20king%20up%20best%2Ejpg
  • mcclell%20king%20up%202%20best%2Ejpg
  • mcclellan%20queen%20up%20best%2Ejpg
  • mcclellan%20queen%20up%203%20best%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5FQueen2%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5Fbathfull2%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5Fbathfull%2Ejpg
  • McClennenM10012%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5FbathwithshowerbyKing%2Ejpg
  • wt134%20new%20shower%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5Ffrontdoor%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5FFull%2CDown%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5FFull%2CDown2%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5Fhalfbathdown2%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5Fhalfbathdown%2Ejpg
  • McClennenM1005%2Ejpg
  • McClennenM10013%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5Fbackstairs%2Ejpg
  • McClennenM10014%2Ejpg
  • McClennenM10016%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5FoutsideShower%2Ejpg
  • McClennenM10017%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5FGuesthousedoor%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5Fguesthousebath%2Ejpg
  • McClennenM10020%2Ejpg
  • McClennenM10021%2Ejpg
  • McClennenM10022%2Ejpg
  • McClennenM10023%2Ejpg
  • McClennenM10024%2Ejpg
  • McClennenM10026%2Ejpg
  • McClellan%5Fguesthouseview%2Ejpg
  • Artisans%20Fair%20%26%20FarmersWT310010%2Ejpg
  • Glass%20Works%20WT310003%2Ejpg
  • Arrow%20Head%20Farm%20WT310006%2Ejpg
  • Agricultural%20Fair%20WT1001%2Ejpg
  • Alleys%20General%20Store%20WT1003%2Ejpg
  • Field%20Gallery%202%20WT1007%2Ejpg

Mill Pond House is a completely restored 1840s farmhouse originally adjacent to the famous Mill Pond in historic West Tisbury on the island of Martha’s Vineyard. It was remodeled by the present owner, an interior designer. It is beautifully appointed with antiques, charming accessories, and comfortable furnishings. An old pine floor and columns add to the ambience of the interior. The first floor has been converted to an open space plan with a cozy living room with a brand new 43" smart t.v., fully equipped kitchen, and a charming dining area seating eight, and kept always comfortable with our new air conditioning. There is also a double bedroom with half-bath as well as a screened porch with a dining table, a seating area and beautiful view of the spacious deck, container plantings, and expansive yard. Upstairs there is a king, queen and twin bedrooms; two with a beautiful pond view, all with air conditioning. Laundry facilities are conveniently located in one of the two full bathrooms. The main house is 2,700 square feet and there are 4 T.V.'s on the property.. THE SUMMER HOUSE An adjacent old original barn converted to a studio with living space, a half-bath, bar sink and WiFi serves as a wonderful private space for work or play. For extra comfort there are three more beds. The property is fenced in the front to secure small children. A shed holds all beach equipment, towels, chairs, games, toys, etc. The back yard vista provides a lovely pastoral setting often enhanced by brilliant sunsets. OUR HISTORIC REGION The house is within walking distance to the quaint colonial town of West Tisbury dating from the 1600s where Indians and colonists (including the son of Myles Standish, the Mayhews, and other settlers) came to grind their corn and exchange goods. Today it holds the first church on the island, an amazing new library, Alley’s General Store, an art gallery, and craft/antiques shows. not to be missed


Rental Overview:

  • Price Range:$3,000 - $5,000
  • Minimum Days Renting: 7 Days
  • Security Deposit: $500.
  • Cleaning Fees: $350. per week
  • Check In: 4:00 PM
  • Check Out: 10:00 AM
  • Property ID: WT134

Notice: Rates and availability are subject to change without notice until confirmed. State and local taxes apply.

Send this Page to a friend?




JUNE 2025
S M T W T F S Cost
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
$3,500.
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
$3,500.
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
$3,500.
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
$3,500.
29
30
          $5,500.
               
JULY 2025
S M T W T F S Cost
   
1
2
3
4
5
$5,500.
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
$5,500.
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
$5,500.
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
$5,500.
27
28
29
30
31
    $5,500.
               
AUGUST 2025
S M T W T F S Cost
         
1
2
$5,900.
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
$5,900.
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
$5,900.
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
$5,500.
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
$5,500.
31
            $4,000.
SEPTEMBER 2025
S M T W T F S Cost
 
1
2
3
4
5
6
$4,000.
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
$3,500.
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
$3,500.
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
$3,500.
28
29
30
        $3,500.
               



Make a Reservation Request:








Rental Overview:


  • Location West Tisbury
  • Number of bedrooms 4 Plus Guest
  • Number of bathrooms 3
  • Accommodates 8
  • Turnover Day Flexible
  • Distance To Beach TBD
  • House Style Colonial Farmhouse
  • Parking Yes
  • Square Footage 2,400 Sq Ft + 430 Sq Ft
  • Property Size .95 Acres
  • Pets No
  • Ferry Tickets No
  • Water View No
  • Waterfront No
  • General Amenities:


  • Air Conditioning Yes
  • Ceiling Fans Studio
  • Fans Yes
  • Iron & Board Yes
  • Phone Landline Yes, Local Only
  • Sofa Bed Yes
  • Vacuum Yes
  • Washer Yes
  • Dryer Yes
  • Heating Electric
  • Outdoor Amenities:


  • Grill Gas and Charcoal
  • Deck Yes
  • Patio No
  • Screened Porch Yes
  • Outdoor Furniture Yes
  • Pool No
  • Tennis No
  • Dock No
  • Beach Access West Tisbury Beaches, Lambert's Cove, Long Point
  • Beach Chairs Yes
  • Grassy Yard Yes
  • Bedrooms - Floor Level:


  • Bedroom 4 Full, down w/ half bath
  • Summer House Bedroom Sleeping for four, Day bed
  • Main Bedroom King, up
  • Bedroom 2 Queen, up
  • Bedroom 3 Twins, up
  • Bath Configurations:


  • Full Bath Shower, up
  • Full Bath Bath and Shower, up
  • Half Bath en suite
  • Half Bath Summer House
  • Outside Shower Yes
  • Bedroom Linens:


  • Sheets No
  • Bath Towels No
  • Beach Towels No
  • Kitchen Amenities:


  • Dinner Seating 8+
  • Dishwasher Yes
  • Stove Gas
  • Microwave Yes
  • Coffee Maker Yes
  • Toaster Yes
  • Blender Yes
  • Food Processor Small
  • Lobster Pot Yes
  • Pots & Pans Yes
  • Bakeware Yes
  • Dishes Yes
  • Entertainment/Technology:


  • Internet/WiFi Yes
  • Cable/Satellite Cable Yes
  • Television Yes, Four
  • DVD Player No
  • Stereo No
  • Board Games Yes
  • Yard Games Yes
  • Special Amenities:


  • Detached Guest/Studio with Half Bath