Karen M. Overtoom Logo
Your connection to all Martha's Vineyard Real Estate and Vacation Rentals
508-693-7832
Karen M. Overtoom Logo
508-693-7832

Real Estate for Sale in West Tisbury on the Island of Martha's Vineyard


  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 44520-1
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 44520-2
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 44520-3
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 44520-4
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 44520-5
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 44520-6

  • LINK ID: 44520
    (31 Josiah Sachem Way )
  • Price: $4,650,000.00
  • Town/City: West Tisbury
  • Type: Multi Family
  • Address: 31 Josiah Sachem Way
  • Year Built: 1989
  • Rooms: 15
  • Bedrooms: 6
  • Baths: 3.5
  • Half Baths: 1

An Inspirational Oasis - Come unwind and experience a secluded multi-dwelling compound nestled along the gentle slopes of Indian Hill, where rural tranquility meets effortless island living on more than three acres of uncommon beauty. Centered around a heated saltwater pool reminiscent of a private resort, the main house, studio barn, and guesthouse with a total of 4,464 square feet of living space, unfold gracefully amid open wildflower meadows and richly layered perennial gardens. Ornamental plantings, old-growth trees, and stretches of velvety lawn create a natural flow between the dwellings, each thoughtfully positioned to balance privacy, connection, and year-round comfort. The main house anchors the compound with glass doors and sun-filled windows framing idyllic landscapes beyond, drawing natural light throughout the interior. A timeless stone fireplace grounds the living room, which flows seamlessly into the dining area and thoughtfully appointed kitchen, spaces equally suited for vibrant gatherings and quiet, unhurried evenings. The Studio Barn offers a rare sanctuary with exceptional potential for multi-generational living, creative pursuits, wellness retreats, or a serene island escape. Tucked quietly away, the Guest House is a two-story retreat offering three bedrooms, one-and-a-half baths, and a loft-inspired living space filled with warmth, character, and flexibility, ideal for visiting guests or extended stays. Together, three dwellings, seven bedrooms, four-and-a-half baths, and one breathtaking property with boundless potential. Residents of West Tisbury enjoy access to Lambert's Cove Beach and Long Point Beach and Wildlife Refuge, along with nearby village eateries, farm stands, winding trails, bike paths, and the natural beauty of Cedar Tree Neck Sanctuary, all just moments away. Rural, convenient, and utterly unforgettable, this beloved island retreat is poised to inspire generations to come. Three Dwellings. One Property. Endless Possibilities.

Contact Karen Overtoom Real Estate:

Preferred method of contact:


Send this property to a friend?




  • Water Type: Well
  • Sewege: Septic Tank
  • Zoning: RU
  • Stove Type: Stove: Yes,Washer: Yes - 2 sets in main house (3 sets total - 1 in guest house)
  • Refrigerator: Stove: Yes,Washer: Yes - 2 sets in main house (3 sets total - 1 in guest house)
  • Lot Size: 3.1
  • Heat: GFHA
  • Water Frontage: None,Pasture
  • Yard Type: Private with lush plantings, flowering trees + stunning perennial gardens.
  • Basement: Mechanicals,industrial washer/dryer,storage. Interior and bulkhead access.
  • Parking: Main house has a pea stone circular driveway. All 3 dwellings have multiple vehicle parking areas.
Back to top