Karen M. Overtoom Logo
Your connection to all Martha's Vineyard Real Estate and Vacation Rentals
508-693-7832
Karen M. Overtoom Logo
508-693-7832

Real Estate for Sale in West Tisbury on the Island of Martha's Vineyard


  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 43718-1
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 43718-2
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 43718-3
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 43718-4
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 43718-5
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 43718-6

  • LINK ID: 43718
    (65 Carls Way )
  • Price: $7,300,000.00
  • Town/City: West Tisbury
  • Type: 1 Family
  • Address: 65 Carls Way
  • Year Built: 2005
  • Rooms: 9
  • Bedrooms: 5
  • Baths: 5.5
  • Half Baths: 1

Stylized Private Waterfront Retreat close to town perched along the tranquil shores of the beloved Tisbury Great Pond, this stunning Hutker-designed waterfront home is a seamless blend of coastal elegance and timeless island charm. Designed to capture the essence of Vineyard living, the home features intimate water views, sun-drenched interiors, and carefully curated finishes throughout. From the moment you arrive, you’re greeted by a graceful balance of architecture that blends with the landscape and affords contemporary touches. Vaulted ceilings, exposed beams, and hardwood floors create a warm, welcoming atmosphere, while expansive windows invite natural light and frame views of the water and extensive gardens. Off of the kitchen is a generous screened in porch which serves as an additional living space with views to the Tisbury Great Pond and manicured lawn. This is a sweet connector space to the primary bedroom wing which includes a private deck, spacious bathroom and walk-in closet leading to a discreet outdoor shower designated to the primary wing. The open-concept living space flows effortlessly onto a spacious deck—perfect for entertaining, sunset dining, or simply enjoying the sea breeze. A chef’s kitchen with high-end appliances and custom cabinetry anchors the heart of the home, while serene bedrooms offer peaceful retreats, each with unique character and comfort. There is a bedroom wing with each bedroom having private baths. Both bedrooms have access to a private west facing deck for relaxing in late day sun. Whether you’re enjoying morning coffee by the water’s edge, launching kayaks from your private dock, or strolling to get the morning paper at Alleys, this one-of-a-kind home offers a rare opportunity to experience Martha’s Vineyard at its finest.

Contact Karen Overtoom Real Estate:

Preferred method of contact:


Send this property to a friend?




  • Water Type: Well
  • Sewege: Septic Tank
  • Zoning: RES
  • Stove Type: Stove: Wolf four burner propane stove,Washer: Maytag additional washer in guest house
  • Refrigerator: Stove: Wolf four burner propane stove,Washer: Maytag additional washer in guest house
  • Lot Size: 3.4
  • Heat: GFHA
  • Water Frontage: Pond
  • Yard Type: Lovely manicured lawn and gardens, expansive decks, patios, stonework, dock
  • Basement: Full basement with affording a great space that could be finished off for a gym or rec room.
  • Parking: yes plenty
Back to top