Karen M. Overtoom Logo
Your connection to all Martha's Vineyard Real Estate and Vacation Rentals
508-693-7832
Karen M. Overtoom Logo
508-693-7832

Real Estate for Sale in West Tisbury on the Island of Martha's Vineyard


  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 42713-1
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 42713-2
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 42713-3
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 42713-4
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 42713-5
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 42713-6

  • LINK ID: 42713
    (140 Pond Road )
  • Price: $3,476,000.00
  • Town/City: West Tisbury
  • Type: 1 Family
  • Address: 140 Pond Road
  • Year Built: 1993
  • Rooms: 11
  • Bedrooms: 4
  • Baths: 3
  • Half Baths: 0

Welcome to this beautifully updated and privately situated home in one of West Tisbury’s most desirable associations, offering exclusive access to tennis courts, walking trails, horse pastures, and direct access to the Tisbury Great Pond. Designed for both comfort and luxury, this spacious 4+ bedroom, 3 bathroom property is perfect as a year-round residence or upscale vacation retreat. The first floor features a sun-filled living room with soaring ceilings, ample dining room, a spacious bedroom with a cozy fireplace, and a chef’s kitchen outfitted with brand-new Thermador appliances. Off the front covered porch you enter a large foyer, the side porch enters into a spacious laundry room for ease of island living, while multiple decks and a screened-in porch (with windows for 3 season living) create seamless indoor-outdoor flow. Upstairs, the private primary suite boasts a spa-like bathroom with a jetted tub, walk-in shower, large walk-in closet, and its own private deck—perfect for morning coffee or stargazing. The finished basement includes a sauna, ideal for unwinding after a day at the beach or on the trails, large TV viewing area and additional space for guests. Recent upgrades include a brand-new roof, fully net-neutral solar system, all-new insulation, new heating and cooling systems (ducted heat pump system), new kitchen appliances and a Lutron RadioRA home automation system. The professionally landscaped yard features a lush, irrigated lawn and offers complete privacy, all just minutes from Tisbury Great Pond, Edgartown, the West Tisbury Farmers Market, and other island favorites. This is Vineyard living at its finest and designed for making lasting memories. * Furnishings available for purchase * Owner and tenants in residence until end of August 2025

Contact Karen Overtoom Real Estate:

Preferred method of contact:


Send this property to a friend?




  • Water Type: Well
  • Sewege: Septic Tank
  • Zoning: RES
  • Stove Type: Stove: Thermador Induction range and GE Advantium wall oven,Washer: Samsung washer
  • Refrigerator: Stove: Thermador Induction range and GE Advantium wall oven,Washer: Samsung washer
  • Lot Size: 2.43
  • Heat: Heat Pump
  • Yard Type: yes
  • Basement: Full basement separated into three areas,two unfinished sections for utilities and storage,one large finished area currently set up as TV room and additional sleeping area. There is a sauna on this level as well.
  • Parking: plenty
Back to top