Karen M. Overtoom Logo
Your connection to all Martha's Vineyard Real Estate and Vacation Rentals
508-693-7832
Karen M. Overtoom Logo
508-693-7832

Real Estate for Sale in Edgartown on the Island of Martha's Vineyard


  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 42954-1
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 42954-2
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 42954-3
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 42954-4
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 42954-5
  • Property Details in Aquinnah: 42954-6

  • LINK ID: 42954
    (74 Turkeyland Cove Road )
  • Price: $8,250,000.00
  • Town/City: Edgartown
  • Type: 1 Family
  • Address: 74 Turkeyland Cove Road
  • Year Built: 1986
  • Rooms: 14
  • Bedrooms: 6
  • Baths: 6
  • Half Baths: 2

This distinguished Edgartown Great Pond compound presents an exceptional collection of features and amenities. Situated within a highly desirable, secluded enclave on Turkeyland Cove, the 4.8-acre property includes two residences, a bespoke private in-ground swimming pool, approximately 400 feet of waterfront, outstanding water views, and a private beach lot on the Atlantic Ocean. The principal dwelling offers four bedrooms, exquisite craftsmanship throughout, and a unique setting right along the water. The secondary residence was constructed in 2010 and spans 2,556 square feet, featuring two bedrooms, a three-car attached garage, and a full basement. The buildings are harmoniously integrated with meticulously designed plantings, landscape, and custom-built fencing and gates. The pool area provides a secluded oasis, with an L-shaped gunite swimming pool nicely complemented by two adjacent outbuildings. Expansive lawns gently slope towards the waterfront, and boat access to the Atlantic beach is readily available from the property shoreline. Held by the same owner for over three decades, this property represents an unparalleled opportunity.

Contact Karen Overtoom Real Estate:

Preferred method of contact:


Send this property to a friend?




  • Water Type: Well
  • Sewege: Septic Tank
  • Zoning: RA120
  • Stove Type: Stove: Y,Washer: Y
  • Refrigerator: Stove: Y,Washer: Y
  • Lot Size: 4.8
  • Heat: GFHA
  • Water Frontage: Pond
  • Yard Type: Also included with this sale is the seller's Atlantic beach lot - Map 53 Lot 21 - accessible by boat from Edgartown Great Pond.,Spacious lawns and meadows
  • Basement: Partial basement in main house for utilities. 2nd home has a full unfinished basement.
  • Parking: Peastone driveways lead to both homes.
Back to top