Karen M. Overtoom Logo
Your connection to all Martha's Vineyard Real Estate and Vacation Rentals
508-693-7832
Karen M. Overtoom Logo
508-693-7832

Where to eat and drink on Martha's Vineyard


 

Take Out

The Net Result - the ultimate Fish Market. Lobsters - cooked and ready to go! Fish and chips, sushi, bluefish pate

Shepherd’s Provisions - Small batch cooking Made on Martha's Vineyard. Shepherd's Pie, chocolate, pimento cheese and cheese sticks - perfect picnic food

Black Sheep - Gourmet sandwiches, cheese, baked goods.

Fat Ronnie's Burger Bar - One of the best burgers on the island!

7a Foods - Try the Liz Lemon !

The Food Truck - Rosemary fries and the The Impossible Burger - Vegetarian but you’d never know it!

 

Room with a View

Lobsterville Bar & Grille - Best Sunset on the water. “Pig Wings,” Bang Bang Shrimp, Cap’s Raw Bar - BEST raw bar!

Nancy’s and Donovan’s Reef - Something for everyone! Gyro plate, Dirty Banana

The Lookout Tavern - Overlooking the Oak Bluffs Steamship! Seared Tuna appetizer, Dragon roll, Fried Clams

The Seafood Shanty - Upstairs bar overlooks the Edgartown Harbor and Chappy Ferry! Shrimp Cocktail with a Bloody Mary

 

Casual

Copper Wok - Casual Asian Fare! Spiced potato samosas, General Gau’s Chicken, Rainbow Roll

Little House Cafe - Lovely atmosphere, with diverse menu options! Shawarma, Falafel, Lentil Salad

Offshore Ale - Oak Bluffs Brewery and pub! A local favorite! Detox Bowl Salad, Table-side Peanuts

 

Operation Dinner OUT (and Drinks)

Atlantic Fish & Chop House - Elegance on the harbor! Bacon at the bar, bone marrow, and more

Rockfish - Upscale pub with wood fire pizza oven! Duck Fries - duck confit over french fries

20bynine - Small plates to share! Menu changes daily, charcuterie and cheese board, Whiskey cocktails

La Soffitta - Italian, just like in Napoli! Saltimbocca, Pappardelle al Filetto, Trio di Bruschetta

State Road - Locally sourced modern American! Burger night, house-made ricotta

The Port Hunter - Very lively. Go late for live music! Duck Wings, Buffalo Brussels

 

Romance!

L’Etoile - Casual elegant dining and bar! Grilled Spanish Octopus, Chef’s tasting menu

The Outermost Inn - The most spectacular view in Aquinnah! Prix Fixe menu but MUST have reservation

Detente - Relaxing and delicious! Try the Chef’s Tasting Menu with the wine pairing!

 

Breakfast

Artcliff Diner - Gina knows how to handle breakfast! Black Bean cake and eggs, Eggs Benedict

The Black Dog - Breakfast overlooking the ferry! Home fries deluxe I, Bozo on the bus